Friday, January 13, 2012
By Steve Crum
Had The Iron Lady been made with an actress less capable than Meryl Streep, it would have been a mediocre, passable movie. But Streep headlines, which makes this biography of Britain’s legendary prime minister a must see. The screenplay itself is problematic, but Streep dazzles.
Past holiday seasons have given us The Queen and The King’s Speech, two exceptional films featuring charismatic lead actors and compelling stories. In fact, The Queen’s backstage at the Royal Palace approach was an immediate hook since there has been so little known about the queen’s daily life over the past 50 years. Same goes for King George in The King’s Speech.
Margaret Thatcher, Great Britain’s prime minster from 1979-90, is another story--a less interesting story. Director Phyllida Lloyd (Mama Mia!) and screenwriter Abi Morgan are not entirely to blame for this failure. That is because Thatcher’s life lacks verve. If only her husband, the humorous and eccentric Denis (Jim Broadbent), were the sole focus of The Iron Lady. That would have been a far more interesting story. What a whimsical soul he evidently was, according to his depiction here. When Denis does (frequently) appear, the film bursts alive and fresh.
A base problem is the very nature of Margaret Thatcher’s Conservative Party-based, political career. Add to that her persona, including a droll, tempered speaking manner. One plus one equals conservatism at its most orthodox.
Specifically, the plot is told in flashbacks from the vantage point of 24 hours in the present day life of long retired Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. It is obvious she suffers from dementia, but this is implicit via actions, and never actually said. (Baroness Thatcher, in fact, is still living at 86, and reportedly has dementia issues.)
Canvased in is Thatcher’s working class childhood, followed by challenges early on as a female breaking into male dominated politics of The Tory Party. (Alexandra Roach is fine as the young Maggie.) Echoing last year’s The King’s Speech, Thatcher is coached in proper speech techniques, particularly enunciation.
More flashbacks recall her rise to the House of Commons as a Conservative, and her destiny as Great Britain’s first female prime minister. The story segues back to present and so on, with Jim Broadbent’s terrific portrayal of Denis shown in real time (the past) and as a wise cracking ghost (present) that only Margaret can see and hear through her skewed sense of reality.
During her tenure of office, Thatcher initiated The Falklands War, and dealt with the sinking of the Belgrano. She was also burdened with her country’s economic and unemployment issues. These events are included in The Iron Lady, but not elaborated upon. In other words, there are no Falklands battle scenes, which is wise since that would detract from the gist of the story. Then again, this script could have used the adrenaline.
Yet we have Streep. More than just the greatest character actress of our time, she is the greatest, living film actress, period. Her Margaret Thatcher is no caricature, she becomes Thatcher.
It is a jolting, Oscar caliber portrayal amidst a mostly prosaic film, Jim Broadbent’s sequences being another exception.
GRADE on a Scale of A to F: B-
--------------------You'll get a hint of the greatness of The Iron Lady: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZrAKdlX0SA
Monday, January 9, 2012
By Steve Crum
Alexander Payne’s serio-comic The Descendants was awarded Best Film among 25 nominees at Sunday night’s (Jan. 8) voting of The James Loutzenhiser Awards by Kansas City Film Critics Circle members. The movie, directed and co-written by Payne, stars George Clooney as a Hawaiian-based attorney dealing with a land development issue as well as his two daughters and comatose wife. Clooney was named Best Actor.
Terrence Malick’s controversial The Tree of Life garnered a Best Director win. Officially, it is named The Robert Altman Award for Best Directing, due to Altman’s Kansas City roots. The movie also won for Best Supporting Actress, Jessica Chastain.
The complete list of winners:
BEST FILM...THE DESCENDANTS
ROBERT ALTMAN AWARD FOR BEST DIRECTING...TERRENCE MALICK
BEST ACTOR...GEORGE CLOONEY (The Descendants)
BEST ACTRESS...KIRSTEN DUNST (Melancholia)
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR...CHRISTOPHER PLUMMER (Beginners)
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS...JESSICA CHASTAIN (The Tree of Life)
BEST ANIMATED FILM...RANGO
BEST FOREIGN FILM...A SEPARATION
BEST DOCUMENTARY...CAVE OF FORGOTTEN DREAMS
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY...BEGINNERS
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY...MONEYBALL
VINCE KOEHLER AWARD FOR BEST SCIENCE FICTION, FANTASY OR HORROR FILM...HUGO
The last award is in tribute to long-time KCFCC critic and sci-fi, fantasy, horror fan, the late Vince Koehler. The James Loutzenhiser Awards is named for the late Dr. James Loutzenhiser, founder of the KCFCC.
--------------------Presenting The Descendants' trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWHNXJ1K4yA